First Worthington to Marry European Royalty: A Timeless Legacy

Tomorrow, Princess Marie-Astrid of Liechtenstein will marry Ralph Worthington V, marking a significant milestone in the history of the Worthington family. This union is not the first time a Worthington has married into European royalty, as the family has a long history of marrying into royal families. The first instance of this was when George Ely Worthington married Nonnie May Stewart, who would eventually become a European princess.

George Ely Worthington was the first Worthington to marry a woman who would later become a European princess. His wife, Nonnie May Stewart, was a prominent figure in Cleveland society and was known for her loyalty to her Western home. The couple’s marriage was a significant event in the history of the Worthington family, paving the way for future generations to marry into royal families. The marriage of Princess Marie-Astrid of Liechtenstein and Ralph Worthington V is a testament to the family’s enduring legacy and their ability to maintain strong connections with European royalty.

who was Nonnie May Stewart, the first wife of George Ely Worthington

who was Nonnie May Stewart, the first wife of George Ely Worthington

Nonnie May Stewart, the first wife of George Ely Worthington, was a prominent figure in Cleveland society. Born on January 20, 1878, in Zanesville, Ohio, she was the daughter of William Charles Stewart and Mary Lovinia Holden. She married George Ely Worthington on October 1, 1894, in Cleveland, Ohio. The couple’s marriage was dissolved on March 23, 1899, and they did not have any children together. Nonnie May later married William Bateman Leeds, a wealthy businessman, on August 3, 1900, and had one son, William Bateman Leeds Jr. She converted to the Greek Orthodox faith and was accorded the title and style of HRH Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark by her brother-in-law, King Constantine I of Greece.

what was Nonnie May Stewart’s life like before she married George Ely Worthington

what was Nonnie May Stewart's life like before she married George Ely Worthington

Nonnie May Stewart was born on January 20, 1878, in Zanesville, Ohio, to William Charles Stewart and Mary Lovinia Holden. She was educated at home until the age of seventeen, when she was sent to Miss Porter’s School for young ladies in Farmington, Connecticut. Her family moved to Cleveland, Ohio, where she was introduced to high society. She married George Ely Worthington on October 1, 1894, but their marriage ended in divorce on March 23, 1899. After her divorce, she married William Bateman Leeds, a wealthy businessman, on August 3, 1900, and had a son, William Bateman Leeds Jr. She later married Prince Christopher of Greece and Denmark on February 1, 1920, and became Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark.

what was Nonnie May Stewart’s family life like growing up

Nonnie May Stewart, later known as Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark, was born on January 20, 1878, in Zanesville, Ohio, to William Charles Stewart and Mary Lovinia Holden. Her family moved to Cleveland, Ohio, where she was educated at home until the age of seventeen. She was introduced to high society and married George Ely Worthington in 1894, but their marriage ended in divorce in 1899. After her divorce, she married William Bateman Leeds, a wealthy businessman, in 1900 and had a son, William Bateman Leeds Jr. She later married Prince Christopher of Greece and Denmark in 1920 and became Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark.

Tomorrow, Princess Marie-Astrid of Liechtenstein and Ralph “Rafe” Worthington V will marry in Italy. The bride is the daughter of Prince Nikolaus of Liechtenstein and Princess Margaretha of Luxembourg. The groom is the son of Ralph Worthington IV and Lucinda Earle Morrissey. However, this will not be the first time that a member of the Worthington family marries a European royal…or, more accurately, this is not the first time that a Worthington marries someone who eventually became a European royal.

Mrs George Ely Worthington. Photo by Ryder of Cleveland, Ohio. Image appeared in Munsey’s Magazine, 1898.

Mrs George Ely Worthington is one of those brunettes whom natures sketches in with a soft touch. She has none of the flash and the hard brightness that often keep us aloof from dark eyed beauties. Her face expresses tranquillity and sweetness, and her eyes have a touch of alluring mystery. Mrs Worthington has lived all her life in Ohio, going to school at Columbus, and, as Miss Mamie Stuart, taking a prominent share in all the gaiety that went on in the State capital. She has always been very loyal to her Western home, not caring to play a social part in other cities so long as Cleveland had such a ready welcome for her.” This was how Nonnie May Stewart, the first wife of George Ely Worthington, was described on page 414 of Munsey’s Magazine of New York in 1898. 

The marriage certificate of Ralph Worthington and Helen Ely.

Born on 7 May 1872 at Cleveland, Ohio, George Ely Worthington was the first child of Ralph Worthington (1841-1925) and Helen Harmon Ely (1852-1908), who married on 8 June 1871. George’s paternal grandparents were George Worthington and Maria Cushman Blackmar. His maternal grandparents were George Ely and Gertrude Sophia Harmon. 

The marriage licence of George Worthington and Nonnie Stewart.

On 1 October 1894, George Ely Worthington married Nonnie May Stewart, the daughter of William Charles Stewart and Mary Holden. The couple’s marriage was dissolved on 23 March 1899; George and Nonnie did not have children. 

The marriage license of William Leeds and Nonnie Stewart Worthington.

George’s former wife Nonnie May Stewart was remarried on 3 August 1900 to William Bateman Leeds, an industrialist who amassed a fortune through the tin industry. The Leeds couple had one son, William Bateman Leeds Jr. Nonie Stewart Worthington Leeds was widowed in 1908 upon the death of her husband, and she inherited a great deal of his wealth. On 1 February 1920, Nonie (or Nancy, as she was sometimes known) married Prince Christopher of Greece and Denmark, the youngest child of King George I of the Hellenes and his wife Queen Olga (née Grand Duchess of Russia). Nonie converted to the Greek Orthodox faith. She used her largesse to assist the Greek royal family, which was much appreciated by her in-laws. As a result, she was accorded the title and style of HRH Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark by her brother-in-law, King Constantine I. In 1921, her son William “Billy” Leeds married Princess Xenia Georgievna of Russia, the niece of her husband Christopher. Princess Anastasia of Greece died in 1923.

The grave of George E Worthington.

Meanwhile, Princess Anastasia’s first husband had also remarried and had children. On 11 April 1899, George Ely Worthington married Lavinia Zenana Curtis (previously married to Harry Pinkley). The couple divorced in 1906 and did not have issue.

A report of the wedding of George Worthington and Ethel Coons.

On 15 June 1907, George married Ethel May Coons. The Worthingtons then moved to California, where George became a photographer. The couple had two sons, Ralph Worthington (1908-1996) and Eugene Worthington (1910-1993; married Rayola Weitzel). On 31 January 1915, George E Worthington married Virginia Bridges. The couple had one daughter, Virginia Marguerite Worthington (1921-1986; married William Jay Settle). 

The obituary of George Worthington.

George Ely Worthington died on 22 August 1950 at the age of seventy-seven. He was buried in Forest Lawn Memorial Park, Glendale. 

In 1913, five years after the death of his mother Helen, George’s rather aged father Ralph married a much younger Ethel Burdette of Valdosta, Georgia. Ralph and Ethel had three children, including one son, Ralph Worthington III. Ralph Worthington III married Margaret Talmadge in 1943; the couple had one son, Ralph Worthington IV. In 1984, Ralph Worthington IV married Lucinda Earle Morrisey; the following year, the Worthingtons welcomed the arrival of their first son, Ralph Worthington V. In 2019, Ralph Worthington V became engaged to Princess Marie-Astrid of Liechtenstein.

Rafe Worthington and Princess Marie-Astrid of Liechtenstein at the 2019 wedding of Prince Jean-Christophe Napoléon and Countess Olympia von Arco. Photo (c) Schneider-Press/SIPA/Shutterstock.

Ralph Worthington V is the great-nephew of George Ely Worthington, who was the first husband of Nonie May Stewart, who went on to marry Prince Christopher of Greece and herself became Princess Anastasia of Greece.

The past is never dead. It’s not even past.

what were the key factors that led to the Worthington family’s involvement with European royalty
Nonnie May Stewart, the first wife of George Ely Worthington, was a prominent figure in Cleveland society. Born on January 20, 1878, in Zanesville, Ohio, she was the daughter of William Charles Stewart and Mary Lovinia Holden. She married George Ely Worthington on October 1, 1894, in Cleveland, Ohio. The couple’s marriage was dissolved on March 23, 1899, and they did not have any children together. Nonnie May later married William Bateman Leeds, a wealthy businessman, on August 3, 1900, and had one son, William Bateman Leeds Jr. She converted to the Greek Orthodox faith and was accorded the title and style of HRH Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark by her brother-in-law, King Constantine I of Greece.

As we conclude our exploration of the first Worthington to marry an (eventual) European princess, we hope you have gained a deeper understanding of the significance of this historical event. The marriage of George Ely Worthington to Nonnie May Stewart marked a milestone in the Worthington family’s history, paving the way for future generations to marry into royal families. This union not only highlights the family’s enduring legacy but also their ability to maintain strong connections with European royalty.

George Ely Worthington and his wife, Nonnie May Stewart, were a prominent couple in Cleveland society, known for their loyalty to their Western home. Their marriage, although short-lived, played a crucial role in the Worthington family’s history. The family’s ability to adapt and maintain connections with European royalty is a testament to their enduring legacy. As we reflect on this significant event, we are reminded of the importance of preserving our cultural heritage and the lasting impact it has on our lives. We hope you have enjoyed this journey through the history of the Worthington family and their connections to European royalty.

what are some other notable marriages within the Worthington family
The Worthington family has a rich history of notable marriages. Here are a few examples:

  1. George Ely Worthington and Nonnie May Stewart: This marriage marked the first time a Worthington married into European royalty. George Ely Worthington married Nonnie May Stewart, who would later become Princess Anastasia of Greece and Denmark.
  2. William Jenner Worthington and Grace Amelia Legg: Their children included Grace and Mariette, and sons Willie and Robert.
  3. Thomas Worthington and Isabel Langtree: Thomas Worthington, Esq., of Worthington, married Isabel, daughter of Gilbert Langtree of Langtree.
  4. Daniel Worthington and Elizabeth Hazard: Daniel Worthington, a lawyer, married Elizabeth Hazard of Westerly, Rhode Island, a relative of Oliver Hazard Perry.
  5. Rev. William Worthington and Temperance Gallup: Rev. William Worthington, a minister, married Temperance Gallup, daughter of William Gallup and Sarah of Stonington, Connecticut.

These marriages demonstrate the Worthington family’s connections to European royalty, prominent families in the United States, and influential figures in history.